I wore these for one season and they have been great so far. I bought them as a lighter alternative to my other pair of winter boots which I wear for like -20C. However I found that these boots are actually quite warm also with just a regular winter sock. They're lightweight, well-made and look cute!
I love them. They are extremely comfortable and the style is on top. I live in NYC and walk miles everyday. I like that my feet don't get soaked when it rains and that I can add thick socks when it gets chilly. They do run a bit big, I got a 38 because I'm a 37.5. I had to add padded insoles to fill them up a bit, and it does allow me to wear thicker socks in the winter which turns out to be a good thing for me.