I've had these shoes for nearly a year now, and they still look wonderful even after intensive wear. I do agree with the other review in that the sizes might be a little off (I'm a 9.5 and ordered a 10, which turned out to be too big) so perhaps round down a half size when ordering. I still get compliments on these shoes even though I've worn them a great deal in the last year, and people seem surprised when I say they're vegan. The black isn't as striking as it was when they came out of the box, probably owing the sun, but the color is still plenty dark for my liking. I'm hoping to continue wearing these for another 2 or 3 years at least.
These are unisex shoes so they are actually mens shoes. They do not have the American sizes correct when they are selling them as "women's" shoes, they are using the American mens sizes, calling them the American women's sizes.